Purebred vs. Mixed Breed: Which Is Healthier?

Purebred vs. Mixed Breed: Which Is Healthier?

It’s one of the oldest debates among dog lovers: are mixed-breed dogs really healthier than purebreds? The answer lies largely in genetics.

Genetics and Health

Genes shape everything about us and our pets, from eye color and coat texture to height, temperament, and even the likelihood of certain medical conditions. In dogs, purebreds are bred within a limited gene pool, which means they’re more closely related genetically. This can increase the risk of inherited disorders such as:

Some breeds, especially those with flat faces or brachycephalic dogs, such as Pugs and Bulldogs, have been bred for their distinctive short snouts. Unfortunately, this selective breeding has caused serious health problems over generations. Many now suffer from Brachycephalic Obstructive Airway Syndrome (BOAS),  a condition that makes breathing difficult due to narrow nostrils and windpipes.

What the Research Says

A 2013 study by Bellumori et al. analyzed over 27,000 veterinary records and found that 42% of genetic conditions were more common in purebred dogs, while only 4% appeared more frequently in mixed breeds.

Interestingly, mutts were found to be at higher risk for only three specific conditions:

  1. Patent ductus arteriosus (PDA) – a heart defect where two major blood vessels fail to close properly.

  2. Ruptured cruciate ligament – a knee injury similar to a torn ACL in humans.

  3. Car accidents – statistically, mixed breeds are more often hit by cars, though the reasons remain unclear.

Longevity: Who Lives Longer?

When it comes to lifespan, the difference between purebreds and mixed breeds is small. A study led by Dr. Silvan Urfer at the University of Washington looked at data from over 169,000 dogs and found:

  • Mixed breeds live an average of 14.45 years

  • Purebreds live an average of 14.14 years

The biggest factor wasn’t breed type, but size; smaller dogs tend to live longer regardless of whether they’re purebred or mixed.

The Cost of Health

Because mixed-breed dogs are less prone to certain inherited conditions, they may be considered “healthier” from a genetic standpoint. That can mean fewer veterinary bills over a lifetime, which is an appealing factor for many pet parents.

Mixed breeds also tend to cost less to adopt or purchase. They’re often less sought after due to their less predictable looks and are more commonly found in rescue shelters.

The Bottom Line

Whether you choose a purebred or a mixed breed, every dog deserves love, care, and attention. If you’re adopting or buying, it’s always wise to have your new furry friend checked by a vet for any underlying conditions. Reputable breeders should also screen their puppies to ensure healthier lineages.

Ultimately, while mixed breeds may have a slight genetic advantage, the most important factor is how well you care for your dog, through good nutrition, regular exercise, and plenty of affection.

 

Back to blog